On April 27, Victoria Powell told me that the EPA will conduct a site visit on Witt Farm. Unfortunately, I did not hear anything else about it and there was no report about this in the local news. I therefore decided to write an email to the EPA on 5/12/2014:
"To whom it may concern,
It came to my knowledge that the EPA was called upon and visited what
the Michigan DEQ calls Adrian 25, a central oil processing facility
within city limits that flared off the natural gas of up to 7 oil wells
for more than a year, mostly burning unclean. I reported about this on
my blog, e.g. http://adrianoil.blogspot.com/2014/03/will-city-county-or-deq-do-something.html.
I did not see any official confirmation of this site visit that
supposable happened on 4/29/2014 and nobody contacted me about any
details that could be added to a ongoing investigation.
My questions are now: was there a site visit and what if anything will
happen? If you need a chronology of the violation, please consult with
my blog or respond to this email.
Thanks in advance, Tom"
About two weeks later I received a voice mail from one of the EPA officers that were on site. I returned the call a few days later and was told that the EPA found violations of the Clean Air Act on site and that it was caused by leaks in the system - not as I expected from the flare. The officer did not want to provide me with more details but suggested that I file a Freedom of Information Act
(FOIA) request around June 15, when the final report should have been filed. This sounded reasonable and on June 24th I filed my request EPA-R5-2014-007747 asking for expedited processing due to potential health risks and my plans to inform the public. I was shocked that my request for expedited handling was refused 6/27. I was hoping that the report would still come in reasonable time but I am getting tired of waiting and therefore wrote the below email to the EPA today:
Subject: FOIA Request: EPA-R5-2014-007747 / RE: Fee Waiver and Expedited Processing Determination
"To whom it may concern,
I am very disappointed with the decision of the case officer. I clearly
stated in my application that I intend to disseminate the information to
the general public via my local blog adrianoil.blogspot.com that is
subscribed by many Adrian citizens and any other
channel that I have - including my media contacts. I also clearly
stated that the report should be made available IMMEDIATELY (that means
expedited!) as the EPA investigation found serious violations of the
clear air act on the site and it is my understanding
of democracy and environmental justice that people living close to the
facility should know about existing health threats NOW and not half a
year later!
As this is not the first and only clear misjudgement by environmental
authorities that should safeguard our citizens and the environment I am
slowly seeing how people can think that the Michigan DEQ and the EPA are
biased or severely undermined by polluting
industries.
I EXPECT to receive the report without further delay and without fees
the latest by this Monday! I will disseminate this letter on my blog -
and I will as well cite the officer from the EPA, who gave me the
information on the findings of violations
on site. I promised the officer to hold back until I receive the final
report but due to your agency's policy of delaying information that the
public has a right to know - I will now post what I was told more than a
month ago!"
I am seriously hoping to get this report soon and I will disseminate it here and send copies to the media.
I sincerely hope that we can get this most important information to the public. It seems that I too, had reported this flaring of gas quite some time ago.
ReplyDeletethank you for sharing.
ReplyDeleteRegards
Tom, has there been any advancements with the Savoy violation? I was unable to location any documentation of resolve beyond the letter of violation.
ReplyDeleteAccording to the EPA, settlement discussions remain confidential, but they did conduct another inspection at the Adrian 25 facility on October 6, 2015. That inspection report and accompanying IR videos are available under FOIA. I requested them but did not get them yet. I will post them as soon I receive them.
ReplyDeleteI forgot to say that once the settlement becomes final, it can be requested via FOIA also. I will keep you posted...
ReplyDelete